In this part of the activity, you will evaluate your three critiques of the poem. You will first need to recall what you learned about intentional and affective fallacies in this unit. W. K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley coined both terms. The term intentional fallacy refers to the idea that an author’s purpose or intention in writing a work of literature has no importance in appreciating or critiquing that work. The term affective fallacy refers to the idea that how a work affects a reader or what emotions it arouses in the reader have no importance in appreciating or critiquing that work. Read this Knowledge Article to learn more about New Criticism and the affective and intentional fallacies.

Evaluate your response to part A. Explain the disadvantages of emphasizing background information, such as historical context when critiquing a poem. Be sure to include examples from your analyses.

My answer to Part A:
Let me count the ways. I love thee to the depth and breadth and height My soul can reach, when feeling out of sight For the ends of being and ideal grace. I love thee to the level of every day's Most quiet need, by sun and candle-light. I love thee freely, as men strive for right.

Answers

Answer 1

Answer

Historical/Biographical Approach

Advantages: Works well for some which are obviously political or biographical in nature. Places allusions in their proper classical, political, or biblical background.

Disadvantages: "The intentional fallacy". Tends to reduce art to the level of biography and make it relative rather than universal.

Moral/Philosophical Approach

Advantages: Useful for works that present an obvious moral philosophy. Useful when considering the themes. Doesn't view literature merely as "art" isolated from all moral implications. Recognizes that literature can affect readers and that the message is important.

Disadvantages: "Judgmental"

Formalism/New Criticism

Advantages: Can be performed without much research. Emphasizes the value instead of the context of literature. Virtually all critical approaches must begin here.

Disadvantages: Text is seen in isolation. Ignores the context. Cannot account for allusions.

Answer 2

Historical/Biographical Approach

Advantages: Works well for some which are obviously political or biographical in nature. Places allusions in their proper classical, political, or biblical background.

Disadvantages: "The intentional fallacy". Tends to reduce art to the level of biography and make it relative rather than universal.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of when critiquing a poem?

Formalism/New Criticism

Advantages: Can be performed without much research. Emphasizes the value instead of the context of literature. Virtually all critical approaches must begin here.

Disadvantages: Text is seen in isolation. Ignores the context. Cannot account for allusions.

Thus, these are the advantages and disadvantages.

To learn more about intentional fallacy click here:

https://brainly.com/question/14669739

#SPJ2


Related Questions

what is the relationship between game companies research and gamers actions in the text.

HOW VIDEO GAMES ARE GETTING INSIDE YOUR HEAD — AND WALLET
by Steve Henn, for NPR

Answers

Answer:

Video games are high in demand because it gives the brain a sense of fun or a rewarding feeling when you win a game.

Explanation: Its also a way to be social with friends and get your anger out

Which version of the sentence is most concise?

The reason the trip is delayed is because we have not collected all the fees.
The reason for the delay is the fees for the trip have not yet been completely collected.
The trip is delayed because all the fees have not yet been collected.
The trip's delay is because of all the fees not yet being collected.

Answers

The answer is number 3

Answer:

Okay I know I'm late, but it's number 3. The person who got brainlest is correct.

Explanation:

I got it right on the test-

help me, please don't cheat​

Answers

Answer:

B SECTION

1. Who

2. Which

3. Whose

4. Where

5. Who

6. Who or Which, most likely Who

7. Which

Give me three or four reasons as to why fake news is bad.

Answers

Answer:

1. It can harm others or their reputation

2. Causes mistrust between people

3. Creates problems in the future

4. You could get a lower grade for your info

5. People are less likely to consume or accept info

Explanation:

Hope this helps, have a great day/night :)

Select the lines of the letter below with either a capitalization or a punctuation error, or both.


the way we shared our love of Christ was inspiring!
Dear Jill,
Sarah Adams
I can hardly wait to see you at camp!
Last year Camp was a real experience for me?
That experience was as beautiful as the surroundings of the Pine Forest.
Don't forget to bring your tennis racket, swimsuit, and a Bible.
I'll be at Camp Inspiration on the Sixteenth of this month.
I hope you are as excited, about this retreat, as I am!
I'll bet that's why it’s called Camp inspiration.
Yours in Christ,
Look for Me, on July 16!

Answers

Answer:

See Below

Explanation:

I'll do my best, but I may not get all of them. (Bold is selected)

The way we shared our love of Christ was inspiring! (Capitalization)

Dear Jill, Sarah Adams (I'm confused whats going on here)

I can hardly wait to see you at camp!

Last year, camp was a real experience for me! (Capitalization and punctuation)

That experience was as beautiful as the surroundings of the Pine Forest.

Don't forget to bring your tennis racket, swimsuit, and a Bible.

I'll be at Camp Inspiration on the sixteenth of this month. (Capitalization)

I hope you are excited about this retreat just as much as I am! (Punctuation)

I'll bet that's why it's called Camp Inspiration. (Capitalization)

Look for me on July 16th! (Punctuation and Capitalization)

What did Noah and Abbey find after they sneaked out of their rooms at midnight?

Answers

Coral queen tada so yea

Answer: The Coral Queen

Explanation: I don't have an explanation but it's the Coral Queen

argumentative essay about increasing teachers pay i need alot of help ​​

Answers

Answer:

                                   Solution Proposal

    Solution Proposal New Mexico came in at position 49 in a ranking by a national review for educational quality which measures aspects like high school graduation rates, advanced placement exam results, school finances and pre-K enrollment. New Mexico came just ahead of Mississippi and Nevada overall (Education Week Magazine, 2017).  This ranking shows the poor state of education in New Mexico.  Similarly, in the 2017 college and career metric New Mexico came in last.  College and career metric reviews factors such as poverty levels of a family, education of a parent, kindergarten enrollment, and steady employment (Education Week Magazine, 2017).  The poor state of education in the country is because of a lack of policies that would otherwise improve the education quality in the country.  New Mexico Legislature should, therefore, come up with strategies such as a sliding pay scale for teachers pay that would improve education quality and ensure there is enough funding for the implementation of these policies.

 

    There have been solutions previously suggested by some state leaders. In 2011, Ms. Skandera, the state’s education secretary-designate rolled out an aggressive teacher evaluation system devised to improve student achievement (Education Week Magazine, 2017). However, educators maintained that MS Skandera had shunned other valid ways to judge teachers. The New Mexico teachers resisted the new plan for evaluation.  Educators suggested that MS. Skandera should have given more weight to classroom observations and to stop the idea of starting the assessments gradually.  Furthermore, the state rolled out Principals Pursuing Excellence and Teachers Pursuing Excellence programs, with the aim to mentor educators to increase reading and math proficiency rates among the students.  

Explanation:

The English language is based on Greek. True False

Answers

Answer:False

Explanation:English developed from a Germanic language.

Determine which word best completes the sentence. Use the drop-down menu to complete the sentence.

We stared across the snowy wasteland, shivering in the ___ air.
A.cache
B.dormant
C.frigid
D.insulated

Answers

C- frigid because the air is cold and frigid means cold

Explanation:

We stared across the snowy wasteland, shivering in the frigid air.

hope it is helpful to you

please help me fill these out !!

Answers

Answer:

nick caraway. descriptive phrase I am still a little afraid of missing something if I forget that as my father snobbishly suggested and I snobbishly repeat,a sense of the fundamental decencies is parceled out unequally at birth.

# first impression. I thought nick was initially an old family rich heir so I thought his father was financing him for a time so he could discover himself.

# relationship to other characteristic.

Daisy's cousin,

toms old classmate

Gatsby's friend

books narrator.

100 POINTS!!!! I need the answer TODAY! PLEASE HELP!
Choose one theme represented in "Thank You Ma'am."

Question 18 options:


Giving someone a second chance is an act of kindness.

Taking the time to practice has great benefits.

Being organized is a key to success.

Enjoy all different kinds of weather.

Answers

Answer:

Explanation:

c

Lather and Nothing Else

Explain the conflict the protagonist feels. Is it internal, external, or both?

Answers

Answer:All conflict falls into two categories: internal and external. Internal conflict is when a character struggles with their own opposing desires or beliefs. It happens within them, and it drives their development as a character. External conflict sets a character against something or someone beyond their control.

Explanation:

Answer:

what the other answer said

Explanation:

Help me with these two questions, I’ll give brainliest

Answers

I belive the first one is choice. I have no idea what the other one is.

2
Underline the correct item.
He was lucky escaping/having to escape/
to have escaped/escaped the tsunami.
2 If you stay out in the blazing sun, you
would have got burned/will get burned/
must get burned/got burned.
9 He turned on the TV so that he watch/to
watch/could watch/to have watched the
weather forecast.
4 The weatherman said we will be having/
will have had/ have had/would be having
blizzards next week.
5 We are sleeping/slept/had slept/were
sleeping when the earthquake occurred.

Answers

To have escaped
2. Will get burned
9. Could watch
4. We will be having
5. Were sleeping
Hope that helped

write down the importance of endangered animals​

Answers

Endangered species are very important as healthy ecosystems depend on plant and animal species as their foundations. When a species becomes endangered, it is a sign that the ecosystem is slowly falling apart. Each species that is lost triggers the loss of other species within its ecosystem (their predators). Humans depend on healthy ecosystems to purify our environment (such as air). When a species becomes endangered it is most likely due to loss of habitat and or loss of genetic variation. A loss of habitat can happen naturally. Human activity can also contribute to a loss of habitat by developing housing, industry, and agriculture. These factors reduce the habitat of native organisms.

If someone can answer 5 and 7 fast and correct I’ll mark as brainiest

Answers

Answer:

Explanation:

I need to see the story to answer the questions

U
Nobody lielped
helped her at her school​

Answers

Answer:

what,can I have brainliest because there is no question

What is a narrative flow?

Answers

a narrative flow refers to how a story moves

Answer:

Narrative flow simply refers to how a story moves. A piece of writing with narrative flow is like a peaceful stream, while one without it might be more like a river blocked by a dam.

Explanation:

I can be seen in the night, but I am invisible in the day. What am I?

Answers

Answer:

Stars i think?

Explanation:

Answer:

the moon

Explanation:

Part G Why aren’t the two samples given in Table 1 and Table 2 exactly the same? Why do the two tables lead to slightly different results in the calculations?

TABLE 1
people who wear corrective lenses 762
people who wear glasses 638
people who wear contact lenses 124

TABLE 2
people who wear corrective lenses 745
people who wear glasses 618
people who wear contact lenses 127

Answers

The most likely why there are different results in the calculations in the given samples is because of a parallax error.

What is a Parallax Error?

This refers to a situation where a person who is taking the measurement calculations makes an error based on his angle of viewing which gives him a different value from the original value.

Hence, we can note that parallax error is one of the suspects in this case and it could also be a calculation error or an error which was made when writing down some values.

Read more about parallax error here:
https://brainly.com/question/10585556

What is most likely the reason the writer uses a
problem-solution text structure in this excerpt?
Read this excerpt from "A Student's Guide to Global
Climate Change."
Climate change could make it too hot to grow
certain crops, and droughts caused by climate
change could reduce the amount of water available
for irrigation. Climate change is also likely to cause
stronger storms and more floods, which can
damage crops. Higher temperatures and changing
rainfall patterns could help some kinds of weeds and
pests to spread to new areas. If the global
temperature rises an additional 3.6°F, US corn
production is expected to decrease by 10 to 30
percent.
What can people do about it?
Farmers may be able to prepare for climate change
by planting crops during different times of the year,
or by planting crops that can survive better in hot
and dry conditions,
o to show how much corn yield will decrease if
temperatures rise by 3.6°F
O to inform people of the risks presented to farming
by climate change
O to let people know about the link between climate
change and food shortages
O to propose changes in farming that temperature
increases make necessary

Answers

Answer:

D. To promote changes in farming that temperature increases make necessary

Explanation:

According to this excerpt from "A Student's Guide to Global Climate Change.", the author talks about how climate change can affect the growth of crops, as of he climate is too hot, it can scorch the crops and make them difficult to survive and if it rains much, can cause flooding and destroy crops. Therefore, he uses a problem-solution text to show that there are alternatives to make in case of any climate change.

Therefore, the most likely reason the writer uses a problem-solution text structure in this excerpt is to promote changes in farming that temperature increases make necessary

How is reading a memoir about apartheid different than reading a History textbook about it?

Answers

Answer:

The memoir is a firsthand account, while the history textbook is secondhand. Hope this helps :)

What two incorrect beliefs about the world do westerners hold? (How are they
ignorant about the world?)

Answers

Explanation:

The public is shockingly unaware of the world, and educators and civic leaders need to confront this problem, writes Sanford J. Ungar.

an argumentative essay future and technology?

Answers

Technology now is not reviewed as a matter of fat but it’s pretty princess

Consider the three central figures in these vignettes (Geraldo, Ruthie, and Earl). What might Cisneros be revealing about the community through Esperanza's impressions of these characters?​

Answers

Answer:

their religon...

Explanation:

7. How does Athena relate to Odysseus?
a. She is his mother.
b. Her powers relate to his strategic mind.
C. She answered his prayers.
d. Her powers relate to his arrogance.

Answers

Answer:

D

Explanation:

Alguien puede hacerme un resumen completo del libro Tales with a Twist de BurlingtonBooks? Muchas gracias. Es para un examen del lunes 17 de mayo

Answers

Answer:

Español:

La historia trata de un gigante que tenía un hermoso jardín, pero nunca dejó que nadie entrara a su jardín. Cuando no estaba en su casa, los niños venían a su jardín a jugar. Pero un día, el gigante decidió visitar a su amigo y se fue al reino vecino. El gigante regresó de la casa de su amigo después de siete años. Al ver a los niños jugar en su jardín, los ahuyentó furiosamente y construyó un muro alto alrededor del jardín. Después de que los niños dejaron de ir al jardín, los árboles y las flores estaban tan tristes que perdieron su belleza. No más pájaros vinieron a cantar allí. La primavera estaba en todas partes, pero en el jardín del gigante todavía era invierno. Hasta que una mañana, el gigante vio niños jugando en el jardín. Y llegó la primavera con los niños otra vez. El gigante se dio cuenta de que había sido egoísta y lamentaba mucho lo que había hecho. Dejó que los niños jugaran en el jardín todos los días para que la primavera volviera con los niños.

Ingles:

The story is about of a giant who had a beautiful garden, but he never let anyone get into his garden. Whenever he wasn't in his house, the children would come to his garden to play. But one day, the giant decided to visit his friend and left for the neighbouring kingdom. The giant came back from his friend's hause after seven years. Seeing the children play in his garden, he angrily chased them away and built a high wall around the garden. After the children stopped coming to the garden, the trees and flowers were so sad that they lost their beauty. No more birds came to sing there. Spring was everywhere but in the giant's garden it was still winter. Until one morning, the giant saw children playing in the garden. And spring arrived with the children again. The giant realised that he was been selfish and he was very sorry for what he had done. He let the children play in the garden every day so the spring could come back with the children.

(no recuerdo si eh visto ese libro o no pero espero que eso te ayude)

What Conflict dose Miss Saunders face when it comes to her students? What is she debating? Support with textual evidence

Answers

Answer:

you didnt leave the paragraph

Explanation:

Plz help! Due tonight!
What is puffery? in your own words

Answers

Answer:

Puffery is something exaggerated.. like for example they complained about school puffery.    (I think think what it means... might not be an accurate example)

Answer:

Kind of like a hyperbole I guess, its an exaggeration that is not proven to be true.

Example: Pretend the doorbell rings.

"I think there is someone at the door", *response* "No duh".

I NEED THIS DONE RIGHT THIS SECOND!! PLEASE HELP ASAP!!!
In "Malala the Powerful," how is Malala Yousafzai's viewpoint that education is essential for children around the world best conveyed in the text?


Question 2 options:


She explains that the struggle against illiteracy, poverty, and terrorism can be won through education.



She explains how schools have been bombed by the Taliban to keep children from getting an education.



She explains how the Taliban is afraid of what is written in books, so they destroy them.



She repeats the saying "The pen is mightier than the sword."

Answers

Answer:

See explanation for answer.

Explanation:

In "Malala the Powerful," Malala Yousafzai's viewpoint that education is essential for children around the world is she explains that the struggle against illiteracy, poverty, and terrorism can be won through education.

( Option 1 )

I hope this helps!

Have a lovely night!

option A would be your answer,
She explains that the struggle against illiteracy, poverty, and terrorism can be won through education.

Other Questions
1. Identifica el sujeto y el predicado de las siguientes oraciones. Si hay sujeto tcito indicar a que persona gramatical correspondea. Te ha dado Miguel el telfono?b. A ti te lo dijo Alicia c. Van a anunciar los nombres de los ganadoresd. Le pareci extraa su actitude. Escucharon atentamente sus consejos 2. Identifica el sujeto de estos titulares y clasifcalo segn los dos criterios estudiados12343. Clasificas las siguientes oraciones transitivas e intransitivas a. Han vendido todas las entradas b. El beb llora toda la nochec. Miguel toma un poco ms de jugo d. Surgi la niebla de repente4. Ubica una oracin del tipo requerido que mantenga sentido y coherencia con el temaLa pelcula es una historia clara y directa de Batman; pero tambin es un filme con referencias al pasado del personaje en el cine y la tv. Batman _______________________(oracin copulativa)_____________________________________ el superhroe de DC Comics.The lego Batman Movie retrata a Batman como un superhroe ____________________ (oracin transitiva)5. Localiza el sujeto y el predicado de estas oraciones e indica si son activas o pasivas a. Han sido catalogados los libros recibidosb. La cantante fue efusivamente aplaudidac. Los chicos han sido muy amables 6. Completa las siguientes oraciones compuestasa. Me asombra su actitud porque }b Comeremos en casa y . Find a Pythagorean triplet whose greatest member is 29. 5. Part B: Which of the following phrases from the text best supports theanswer to Part A?O A "The Afrikan regime put up a stiff front" ( Paragraph 16)OB "denounced apartheid as an unacceptable system" ( Paragraph 17)OC "awarded the 1960 peace prize to Albert Luthuli" ( Paragraph 17)OD "Mandela and seven other activists were sentenced to lifetimeimprisonment" (Paragraph 18) Opportunities American consumers experienced The circumference of a circle is 6 2/7 miles. What is the area of the circle in square miles? ( Use 22/7 for pi.) imagine that a small snake in a grassy yard sees you coming. which type of motion would it probably use to move away quickly? Why? Which of the following are considered expenses? Select all that apply: car insurance allowance entertainment store credit The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a 5-3 vote in favor of Mapp. The high court said evidence seized unlawfully, without a search warrant, could not be used in criminal prosecutions in state courts.CAN YOU PUT THIS IN YOUR OWN WORDS??No links or spam i will report. TY! Fill in the blank with the correct form of ser or estar: Nosotros en la sala If 3 ocean waves travel past the end of the pier in 9 seconds and the wavelength of the ocean waves are 15 m long, what is the speed of the ocean wave? What is the meaning of Cinco de Mayo? Give the History of the day. Write at least 100 words. Please please help will give brainliest Which measure is most appropriate to compare the two data sets below?A.medianB.meanC.rangeD.mode How do you find the mean, median, mode, and range of a set of numbers? What is the central idea of this passage?A. Smithsons project took many years to fund and build.B. Smithson was a wealthy aristocrat well-known in Great Britain.C. The U.S. and Great Britain were in conflict over Smithsons fortune.D. Smithson founded one of the greatest American institutions of knowledge. Who were the main writers of the Renaissance? What is the supplement of 12 Read the given paragraph then answer the question that follows:"But one hundred years later, the Negro still is not free. One hundred years later, the life of the Negro is still sadly crippled by the manacles of segregation and the chains of discrimination. One hundred years later, the Negro lives on a lonely island of poverty in the midst of a vast ocean of material prosperity. One hundred years later, the Negro is still languished in the corners of American society and finds himself an exile in his own land. And so we've come here today to dramatize a shameful condition.State the evidence King uses to support his claim that "the Negro is still not free." what problems does "the Negro" still face? Explain by citing textual evidence.Immersive Reader(2 Points) NEED HELP ASAP MIDDLE AGES Evaluate the expression