In Hamdan v. Rumsfeld (2006), the Supreme Court considered whether it had jurisdiction under the Detainee Treatment Act (DTA) of 2005 to consider the habeas corpus petition of Salim Hamdan, who was being held at Guantanamo Bay. Although the dissent argued that the court did not have jurisdiction, a 6–3 majority Supreme Court decided that it did, and proceeded to rule on the merits.

a) Suppose that the federal government wished to strip the Supreme Court of jurisdiction in all habeas corpus petitions of all individuals being held at Guantanamo Bay. Discuss what actions the president or Congress could take to do so. Discuss the potential basis for such power.

b) In the context of the scenario, discuss how such actions by the federal government would promote or interfere with the separation of powers, and discuss the potential constitutionality of any such actions.

Answers

Answer 1

Answer:

Explanation:

a) The president can propose a law stripping the Supreme Court of jurisdiction in all habeas corpus petitions of all individuals being held at Guantanamo Bay and ask the Congress to pass it.

It is based on the power from the US Constitution for the Congress to pass laws and the president to carry them out.

b) Such actions by the president and the Congress are within their powers but will very likely be interpreted as interfering with the separation of powers. It is because they take away power from the Supreme Court which has the power of interpreting the laws by the Constitution.

Answer 2

The Supreme Court will no longer have jurisdiction over any habeas corpus petitions filed on behalf of anyone detained at Guantanamo Bay, according to a proposed law that the president can put forward and have the Congress approve.

It is based on the US Constitution's provision that grants the president the authority to carry out laws passed by Congress.

What is Guantanamo Bay?

The Guantanamo Bay detention center is a U.S. military jail situated inside the Guantanamo Bay Naval Base, often known as Guantanamo, GTMO, on the Cuban coast of Guantanamo Bay. Since the military prison's initial opening in January 2002, when it housed about 780 detainees who had been held there since the September 11 attacks, 735 of them have been relocated, 35 are still there, and nine have passed away while being held.

The camp was built in 2002 as part of the War on Terror after the September 11, 2001 attacks by the administration of American President George W. Bush.

Learn more about Guantanamo Bay, from:

brainly.com/question/10248126

#SPJ2


Related Questions

Question 6 of 10
Which statement best describes an advantage of direct democracy over
indirect democracy?
O A. It can work better for societies with large populations.
O B. It can make decision making more efficient.
O c. It can be more responsive to citizens' interests.
O D. It can be less demanding on citizens' time and attention.
SUBMIT

Answers

I'm pretty sure it's A

Which region of the United States supported Andrew Jackson?

Answers

the southwest of the united states.
Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and both of the Carolina’s along with the entirety of the Southwest.

NEED HELP !!
Instructions in a paragraph answer this question: Do you think Americans were happy during the cold war? 

Answers

Answer:

They were many scared for their life during the cold war. They knew if either the Soviet or U. S. made a wrong move toward the other, they would be wiped out. After the Soviet Union exploded its first atomic bomb in 1949, the American public was understandably nervous.

Explanation:

Therefore, no. I do not think Americans were happy during the cold war. Many people died which was not a great sight either.

can someone please to a repot on ColinPowell plzzz

Answers

Answer:

SUREEEE

PEACE AND LOVE ON THE PLANET EART <33

Explanation:

Why did nazis try to hide evidence of the death camps?

Answers

Answer:

The Nazis tried to destroy their death camps so that there would be no evidence of their atrocities.

Explanation:

Answer: the nazis tried to destroy their death camps to hide evidence of their atrocities.

Explanation:

How did advances in farming technology after World War II impact the population of Georgia?
O A. people moved to rural areas because there were so many jobs there
o
B. people moved to the coast to work in the growing fishing industry
o
C. people moved to cities because farms needed fewer workers
D. people moved out of Georgia because there were no jobs

Answers

- Thousands of people in the rural areas of Georgia on the farms moved North after WW2 in hope of better jobs. - This caused an immense change in the people that worked on the farms, and farms had to condense so there wasn't so much unused land. -This was a law passed in 1944 that allowed soldiers to go to college

I NEED THIS ASAP
What was the Riot Act?

A. A law that prohibited the sale of rifles to farmers?

B. A law that created state militias to suppress rebellions

C. A law that prohibited groups from entering courthouses

Answers

Answer:

b

Explanation

rebellions are like riots

Which New Deal program employed people to build roads, public housing, and sewers?

A) Agricultural Adjustment Act

B) Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation

C) Social Security

D) Public Works Administration

Answers

D) Public Works Administration

Fort Oglethorpe in Georgia was used for which purpose during World War I?
OA.
to manufacture military supplies
B. to hold prisoners of war
OC.
to instruct civilian pilots
OD.
to train medical staff

Answers

Answer: B. to hold prisoners of war

Explanation: During WWI, Fort Oglethorpe was home to 4,000 German Prisoners of War and civilian detainees.

Answer:

to hold prisoners of war

Explanation:

why did japan enter a period of increased warfare after the failed Mongol invasions.

Answers

Answer:  Because the daimyo began arming their samurais to protect their land and castles broke the power of the daimyo and increased their own power.

Why was the Balkan region referred to as the "Powder Keg of Europe" prior to World War 1?'
O
A.
The aggression of the Ottoman
Empire was disrupting
the balance of power.
O
B.
Yugoslavia was invading its neighboring countries.
C.
Nationalistic and imperialistic rivalries were increasing.
D.
The area was the leading supplier of military equipment to the rest of the world.

Answers

The answer is A. Due to the Ottoman Empire’s aggression and that the Balkan states declared independence. With empires like Austria-Hungary and the Ottoman Empire this was the “Power keg of Europe.” After the Death of Franz Ferdinand Austria Hungary declared war of Serbia setting off the power keg. The Ottoman Empire declared war on the allies and helped Austria Hungary.

In an effort to "modernize" Japan, Emperor Meiji did all of the following EXCEPT:

Answers

im pretty sure it’s B

True or False - A communication system transfers information and is made up of a transmitter, signals and a receiver

Answers

Answer:

true

Explanation:

Someone please help me!! Final exam!!
What could be considered the beginning of the Cold War?


A.)Stalin's refusal to remove Soviet troops from Eastern Europe as agreed at Yalta in 1945
B.)Germany's unwillingness to disarm and demilitarize per the peace agreement
C.)China's continued threat to invade Japan following ​World War II​
D.)Japan's demands for reparations from the Allies following the dropping of the atomic bombs

Answers

A. The answer is a. I Just had the final.....

what question could be asked using the 6W about the first black president
plz

Answers

Answer: why is obamba the first black presidant can be asked.

Explanation:

In what system of government does the central government have all the power?

Answers

Answer should be Unitary Systems

Answer:

unitary systems

Explanation:

A unitary system has the highest degree of centralization. In a unitary state, the central government holds all the power.

GOOD LUCK

The empire over which Charles V ruled included the lands of

A. England
B. Russia
C. the Ottoman Empire
D. the Holy Roman Empire

Answers

D. The Holy Roman Empire

Who invaded and stole from the Roman Empire?

Answers

Answer:

The Sack of Rome on 24 August 410 AD was undertaken by the Visigoths led by their king, Alaric. At that time, Rome was no longer the capital of the Western Roman Empire, having been replaced in that position first by Mediolanum in 286 and then by Ravenna in 402.

Explanation:

Hope this helps, have a great day/night :)

The Sack of Rome on 24 August 410 AD was undertaken by the Visigoths led by their king, Alaric. At that time, Rome was no longer the capital of the Western Roman Empire, having been replaced in that position first by Mediolanum in 286 and then by Ravenna in 402.
Location: Rome
Date: 24 August 410 AD
https://en.m.wikipedia.org › wiki
Sack of Rome (410) - Wikipedia

Why were the Democrats able to win the presidency in 2008?

Answers

Answer:

Obama won the first contest in the Democratic nomination season, the January 3, 2008 Iowa Democratic caucus. Obama had the support of 37.6 percent of Iowa's delegates, compared to 29.7 percent for John Edwards and 29.5 percent for Hillary Clinton.

Explanation:

What is the most difficult economic and social problem affecting diplomatic relations between Mexico and the U.S.?

Answers

In 1810, Father Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla calls for Mexican independence from Spain, spurring a series of revolts across the country that becomes known as the Hidalgo rebellion. The rebellion fails, but fighting continues. Meanwhile, the United States and Spain are locked in debate over the border between their territories. In 1819, the Adams-Onis Treaty, also known as the Transcontinental Treaty, draws a definitive border between Spanish land and the Louisiana Territory. The United States cedes California, New Mexico, Texas, and modern Arizona, Nevada, and Utah to Spain; it also agrees to pay U.S. citizens' land claims against Spain up to $5 million.

Please help, I am confused. NO LINKS OR ELSE YOU GET REPORTED.

Answers

Answer:

War bonds your welcome boom

Answer:

b

Explanation:

What was the role of our Religion, faith, belief in the success of the PEOPLE POWER REVOLUTION.​

Answers

The correct answer to this open question is the following.

Although there are no options attached we can say the following.

The role of our religion, faith, belief in the success of the People Power Revolution was the following.

The clergy participation in the EDSA Revolution, also known as the People Power Revolution. played a key role in strengthening the numbers, the will, and the numbers of the people that joined the movement and the demonstration in the city of Manila, Philippines.

Another important issue was that the participation of Priests, nuns, and the clergy in general, was seen as the result of the fact that the EDSA Revolution was a non-violent, peaceful movement.

The demonstrations started in the city of Manila on February 22, 1986, until February 25, the same year. The civil resistance pacifist demonstrations and protests force dictator Ferdinand Marcos to resign after 20 years in power.

Corazón Aquino became the democratically elected president of the Philippines.

What kinds of things could Tio Luis do to Mama because she refused to marry
him?

Answers

Answer:

can take their land away because, as women they were not aloud to own their own property.

HELP ASAP NO LINKS OR ILL REPORT!!!!
_____________

What does Zeus plan to do to the mortals after they made an attack on the gods???

Answers

Answer:

He locked them up deep in the earth. ... Upright like the gods and he lit a torch and brought fire to earth from heaven.

Explanation:

How did John f Kennedy become president ? And why

Answers

Answer:

In the 1960 presidential election, he narrowly defeated Republican opponent Richard Nixon, who was the incumbent vice president. ... Kennedy was the first Catholic elected president. Kennedy's administration included high tensions with communist states in the Cold War.

Explanation:

have a blessed day

what was the reason john karry oppose the Vietnam war

Answers

Answer:

He opposed because he did not believe Americans had committed any atrocities in Vietnam.

Explanation:

An example of a healthy fat would be?



A. Olive Oil


B. McDonald's French Fries


C. Fried Chicken


D. Vegetable Oil

Answers

Answer:

olive oil, it is much better then the other options

Answer:

A is not healthy, B is not healthy, C is not healthy, so it's D.

Explanation:

D is healthy.

Which of the following was true of the Church during the Middle Ages?



A.It had little political authority to guide people’s conduct


B.It created division among people in the same manner as feudalism


C.It unified people with a sense of security and belonging


D.It provided each person with a different path to salvation

Answers

Answer:

c

Explanation:

The Axis Powers shared a vision of a
government.
A. representative
B. hierocracy
C. democratic
D. totalitarian

Answers

Answer:

Totalitarian

Explanation:

All of the Axis Powers nations were ruled by a dictator (Hitler, Mussolini, Hirohito) and had an expansionist policy.

How is Gettysburg different from other battles in the civil war?

Answers

It was the turning point of the war because it forced General Lee and his army to begin a slow, defensive campaign of retreat to their home country for supplies and a fresh stock of soldiers.
Other Questions
Cunto tarda un vehculo en recorrer 26 km con una velocidad constante de100km/h Santos Unlimited (SU) was originally unlevered with 4200 shares outstanding. However, after a major financial restructure, SU now has $37000 of debt, with an annual interest expense of 8 percent. The restructuring has reduced the number of shares to 3800. A group of shareholders of SU are not convinced that this move towards adopting financial leverage is a good idea. Their main argument is that there is now some range of EBIT, however low, that will make the shareholders worse off than before. Required:Help understand the situation better by computing the level of earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) that would make shareholders indifferent between being unlevered (i.e. not having any debt) and levered (i.e. having debt). Assume a 34 percent corporate tax rate. David has decided to build a website about sports equipment. He is now planning the site structure. How should he design the site structure?to use in the alt text, which will beDavid should design theusing logic. He should also select the correctcrucial in attracting relevant traffic and placing his website at the top of search engine results.ResetNext why does glucose more soluble in water comparing to benzoic acid? which graph represents the line of best fit for the scatter plot?? Given ABCD as marked, what additional information would help you to prove that ABCD is a square? Pls I rlly need help How does deep breathing affect the lymphatic and venous (veins) systems? True or False: A second tidal bulge forms on the side of Earth opposite the moon because the moon's gravity pulls Earth away from the water. Ben can jump rope forward, backward, and crossways! An eight-foot rope is too long for his height, so he shortened the rope by nine inches. How long is his jump rope now? help fake answers will be reported During meiosis, homologous chromosomes line up next to each other. In somecases, one arm of a chromatid crosses over the arm of another chromatid. What isthe result of this process?the independent assortment of genetic materialthe creation of an additional sex cellcontinuity in the offspring cell's DNAadditional variation in the DNA of each sex cell formed I need help, correct answer will get brainliest! 1-4 please in FRENCH brainliest will be involved!! HELP ME HEP M HELP HELP HURRU What are the major functions of the male and the female reproductive systems?NO LINKS Pcl3+H2O=H3PO3+Hcl=? Anyone with a knee injury or any doctor! What does it mean if my knee popped locked up all in like 1.5 seconds and then it now hurts to bend but not alot and i can wiggle my kneecap like a lot. This is the 2nd time in like 7-9 months! Please help! Comment if there is no more answers left! 13. Which of the following is one of the components of inclusion?O concernO participationO cooperationo collaboration Track and field is an individual sport.True or False? Describe all the x-values at a distance of 20 or less from the number 12. Enter your answer in interval notation.